All About Learning Press

Sharing is caring!

Choosing the Best Homeschool Curriculum for Your Family

Choosing the best homeschool curriculum for your family is one of the most overwhelming parts of homeschooling. I have a love-hate relationship with it. I love when it comes time to pick out the new year’s homeschooling curriculum. It is like Christmas day!

However, it is so stressful sometimes! There are so many choices and it can be super overwhelming! I have learned so many different things throughout the years. I have picked up tips and tricks along the way to make things go a little smoother, and to reduce some of the overwhelm! Here’s how to choose the best homeschool curriculum for your family.

Related Post: How to Start Homeschooling: Step by Step Guide

Don’t forget to grab your free curriculum planner at the bottom of this post! Then enter the giveaway to win a Science curriculum of your choice from Apologia!!

[mailerlite_form form_id=2]
Choosing the Best Homeschool Curriculum for Your Family

This post contains affiliate links. Which means I may receive a commission if you click on one of my links. (At no extra charge for you.) Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. To read more about how my affiliate links work, click here.

Choosing the Best Homeschool Curriculum for Your Family

What Subjects Should I be Teaching?

The subjects that should be taught to your child should be listed on your state’s board of education website. I have listed the common subjects that should be taught each year starting in the elementary years. Math Language Arts (Grammar, Spelling, Reading, Writing, etc.) Science Health Foreign Language History/ Social Studies Geography Other (Art, PE…

*Check with your local board of education. Some states will require your subjects to align with public school education.

Textbooks vs. Living Books

To start, we will discuss textbooks and living books.


Textbooks are books similar to what you would use in public schools. It is a book full of a set curriculum that you follow throughout the year. Ex. Saxon Math

993478: Saxon Math 5/4 Homeschool Kit, Third Edition
Saxon Math 5/4 Homeschool Kit, Third Edition

Living Books:

Living books are stories that are told in an interesting way by the author. They are books that are not just dry facts. For example, stories and events in history could be woven throughout the book, or it could simply be a biography of a historical figure.

Ex. Ben and Me

(A story of Benjamin Franklin)
Choosing the Best Homeschool Curriculum for Your Family 1

If you are interested in using the Charlotte Mason method I suggest reading this post about A Gentle Feast. >>> A Gentle Feast Curriculum Review

Online Learning

There are plenty of online learning options out there. Online learning is a curriculum that is done completely online. There is little to no preparation involved in this curriculum. Ex. Monarch, Time for Learning, K-12

AOP Homeschooling Products

Where to Purchase Curriculum

My favorite place to do my curriculum shopping is Christian Bookstore. They have great prices and have pretty detailed previews of all the curriculum. (By far the best previews that I have seen.) I like to see inside the curriculum before I make my purchase! Even when I use another place to purchase my curriculum, I still use Christian Bookstore to do some research.

Rainbow Resources

This one is the closest to Christian Bookstore, but they don’t have as wide of a selection. I also think that Christian Bookstore has slightly better prices.


Ebay is great for purchasing used curriculum packages. If you go for a curriculum like My Father’s World or Heart of Dakota, you can find used packages for steals!

Facebook Curriculum Buy, Sell, Trade Groups

These are another good place to find used curriculum, and sometimes nearly new! Scamming does happen, however, so just be aware of the site rules, and make sure the seller is following them. For this reason, Facebook groups are usually my last resort. I have purchased a few items from them and never ran into any problems. That doesn’t mean that it can’t happen though.

Local Stores

Stores such as Mardels sell curriculum. This gives you a chance to look inside!! We have no stores that sell homeschool materials in our area, so I just stick to ordering online.

Company Sites

Places like A beka, BJU, Milestone Books (sells Rod and Staff), Demme learning, All About Learning, and etc. can be a good option, too. The pros of buying straight from the company are that they usually give a more in-depth look into the curriculum and they sometimes offer specials that other retailers may not offer. The cons would be that they may not offer free shipping, and you can’t purchase everything in the same place. (Which I really like to do.)

New Vs. Used Curriculum

So, you may be wondering about the benefits of using new curriculum vs. using a used curriculum. Well, I am going to give you the scoop, and let you decide for yourself!

New Curriculum Pros

Brand new No wear and tear (writing, missing papers, etc.). The latest updated version may stand up against wear and tear for longer.

New Curriculum Cons


Used Curriculum Pros

Cost! You can get it for a fraction of the cost. Helping out another homeschool family.

Used Curriculum Cons

Could have wear and tear. Possibly Outdated may not last as long. There are some things we always buy new, like workbooks and consumables. I also don’t mind buying Math brand new because it will be passed down through all 4 of my children.

Storing Curriculum

What do you do with the curriculum while you are not using it? Well, for some people, the answer would be to sell it. (We will cover that in a bit.) But, if you are wanting to use the curriculum for multiple children, you may want to store it. We store our curriculum in large totes. (We typically only keep the curriculum that we love.) Wherever you choose to store your curriculum, make sure it will be safe from water damage, dust, and anything else. You don’t want your curriculum to be ruined the next time you pull it out for a child to use.  

So what’s right for your family??

If you haven’t already figured out your child’s learning style, you should do that>>here. Learning and teaching styles are important in figuring out what kind of curriculum to use. Also, decided on a homeschooling method. (Read more about homeschool methods here.) All those things play an important role in picking out the best curriculum for your family.

Check out our Curriculum Choices for 2019-2020 School Year.

Other things to consider:

What is your budget? Do you want your children to work independently for the most part? How much time do you have to dedicate to homeschooling?

In the end…

It may take a few tries (or so) to find something that really works well for your family. So, don’t think it has to happen the first time you purchase a curriculum. Some people find what they are looking for early on in their homeschooling journey, and they stick to it. Others (like me) take a bit longer to find that perfect fit. It is perfectly ok if you have to switch curriculum out several times before you find what is best for your family.

Grab Your Free Curriculum Planner: Curriculum Planner

Grab Your Free Curriculum Planner:
choosing the right homeschool curriculum

Could you use some free curriculum?

If so, you’re going to love this giveaway! Now through Sunday, September 22, you can enter to win your choice of a science curriculum from Apologia!

To enter, just fill out the entry card below. You can pick and choose which entry options you complete, and along the way, you’ll find some fantastic new homeschool bloggers to follow!

In addition, by entering you will also receive a Digital Swag Bag valued at $60 – so everyone who enters gets free curriculum resources! You can find the details of the Swag Bag below the entry.

It is your responsibility to read the terms and conditions upon entering. Entering this giveaway signs you up for the following email newsletters: The Fervent Mama, Life Beyond the Lesson Plan, The Art Kit, Peace Creek on the Prairie, Brookdale House, My Joy-Filled Life, The Unexpected Homeschooler, Finding Joy in the Journey, and With the Huddlestons email if you aren’t already subscribed. The winner has 48 hours to claim their prize before a new winner is drawn. Giveaway ends September 22nd, 2019 at 12 AM CST. 

Use the rafflecopter link below to enter:

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Swag Bag Details:

All entrants will receive the Swag Bag (valued at $60) within 24 hours of the giveaway closing. 

With the Huddlestons

Science Experiments That’ll Blow Your Mind It comes with 4 videos and printable worksheet pages that are needed to complete each experiment. This is the perfect self-paced course for the science explorer looking to be wow’d! This is a $20 course!

The Unexpected Homeschooler

Career Exploration Worksheets This is a course teens can do to explore what careers would be best for their personalities, interests, and strengths.

Peace Creek on the Prairie

– The All About Animals an early childhood resource packet is filled with eleven lesson plans for elementary aged children to teach children valuable science lessons. $12 value

Brookdale House

– Thirty Pages of Panda Themed Handwriting practice including letter tracing practice.  The fun panda graphics will help your child look forward to the next page of practice.

The Art Kit

– Outer Space 3-Part Cards (4 sheets that include Sun + Planets) and STEAM Challenge Color Mixing Activity Cards. $10 value.

The Fervent Mama

Our Bible Trivia for Kids Game Kit includes 54 printable pages of fun for ages Elementary and up! Valued at $15, each set of questions is sorted by difficulty and labeled by categories. There are 240 questions total; 40 Level 1, 60 Level 2, 110 Level 3, and a Bonus 30 adult questions. ($15 value)

choosing the best homeschool curriculum

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Reply